Scotty McCreery, "I Love You This Big"

After receiving the majority of the 122 million votes cast during Tuesday night’s American Idol performance show, Scotty McCreery was named this year’s Idol winner over Lauren Alaina. Just like the previous 9 Idols have done, McCreery is releasing his first single which is titled “I Love You This Big.” Is this the most appropriate song to launch Scotty into country superstardom?

I’ve been an American Idol fanatic since its first season and I have become a fan of many of its winners including country superstar Carrie Underwood as well as the original winner, Kelly Clarkson. Those two alone have proven that winning the competition can lead to a successful career in the music industry. The only problem with winning the show is that you have to release a cheesy debut single chosen for you as the winner. Kelly had “A Moment Like This” and Carrie had to release the awful “Inside Your Heaven.” These songs didn’t prove to be launching pads for their careers, but the songs that were released right after those singles proved to be the spark their careers needed (“Miss Independent” for Clarkson and “Jesus Take the Wheel” for Underwood).

The point I’m trying to make here is that “I Love You This Big” is, in fact, one of those cheesy songs that the Idol winner has to release. That’s the reason why I’m not going to take it too seriously because I’m hoping that the single McCreery chooses to release after this song will be one far suited for his artistic style. The song tells the story about how the narrator is in experience young love with a girl. When you listen to the lyrics of the first verse, it actually isn’t a bad song. Then the last line of the verse hits and goes into the chorus and that’s when it loses me: “I might look a little silly standing with my arms stretched open wide I love you this big…” It’s all a bit cheesy and reminds me of a little kid telling his mom how much he loves her by stretching his arms as far as he can rather than a guy telling a girl how much he loves her.

I have to admit that from a production standpoint Jimmy Iovine (the season long mentor) did a great job in sticking to Scotty’s traditional country roots. That was my biggest fear for Scotty because I figured he’d get stuck releasing a pop-leaning song rather than a true country song. But this song is filled with plenty of steel guitar and includes a fantastic guitar melody that keeps the song leaning on the more traditional side of country music. It is actually one of the best productions I’ve heard on a country song in some time, which is rather surprising.

Scotty’s money maker is definitely the lower range of his voice which he shows off beautifully in the verses and during the first chorus. When the song hits the bridge he dabbles with his higher register which also sounds spectacular. His voice is perfectly suited for traditional country and I hope he continues to record more traditional leaning material (that’s if his Idol handlers allow him to go down that road).

With the last country Idol winner Carrie Underwood having such a huge career post-Idol, it’ll be interesting to see if Scotty McCreery can live up to that success. I think it’ll all depend on his song choices for not only his debut album, but for his debut single. However he’ll no doubt have some of Nashville’s best songwriters bombarding him with their best work so I think he’ll have no trouble with choosing songs. I’m going to predict that Scotty will become one of country’s leading men in the next few years.


Filed under Single Reviews

4 responses to “Scotty McCreery, "I Love You This Big"

  1. Thank you, Thank you, Thank you! Finally someone who gets it! So many reviews have blamed all this on Scotty when it's really just part of winning. I am not a teenager and look forward to hearing his next release. I predict that Scotty will have an amazing career. Man, he's only 17! Love, love, love his voice!

  2. I think Scotty definitely has the potential to have have a successful career in country music. But like I said in the review, it'll all come down to song choice. That's what will make or break his career. So I'm hoping he doesn't get caught up in what the Idol people want him to do and hopefully he'll be able to go down the traditional mainstream route like Josh Turner and Chris Young have done.

  3. I am 64 year old (still pretty hip) female who likes all kinds of music and except for one episode that was taped, I have never missed an Idol show. I have also been pretty successful at picking the winner just about every year. I also knew Jennifer Hudson was gonna do something big, but never in my wildest dreams….. But I have to tell you that Scotty McCreery beats them all in my book. First he has the purest voice you can imagine, he sparkles so naturally every time he appears on stage and he was the only contestant that NEVER EVER lost the top spot. I am going to bet that this song will go to No. 1 on the Country Billboard w/i the first week. Maybe the first day! I believe it will be one of the biggest country songs of the year and everyone will want a duo with this young man who says he is gonna take Lauren Alaina with him. Now they are a fabulous duet! The word "cheesy" doesn't even begin to explain this song. My husband downloaded the actual song to be released and I could listen to his voice and those words 101 times before I ever get tired. It is the sweetest of love songs and I believe more people than not will relate to what it means when you say "I Love You This Big." I LOVE YOU THIS BIG Scotty McCreery (and Lauren Alaina as well). A 17 year old H.S. student will end up being the biggest Idol star ever. And absolutely, with no question, the one with the most heart, soul, and so much class. It cut into the song, but what a wonderful thing he did to personally thank everyone right after he won. It touched my heart. His Mama and Daddy should be very very proud. I will definitely be at the Idol concert in Orlando this year and can't wait for his first album.

  4. I agree about his success depending on future song choice, but there is no doubt he has the talent to make it big if his management does not mess him up.I like the song itself, it stirs both happy and sad emotions for me, it voices the way I feel for my late wife of 31 years who passed away suddenly from multiple cancers diagnosed only a little less then 3 month before her passing. She would have loved the song as well if she had been here to hear it.I am not an Idol fan but for some reason I was drawn to the first few weeks and knew Scotty was going to be a hit whether he won or not!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s